Private and Public A La Mode

nuances to public notification in fire and life safety


A reader from Ohio wrote: “I’m always running into trouble over how many horns and strobe lights are necessary. Is occupant notification always required?”

No, building-wide occupant notification is not always required, but some kind of notification is always required. NFPA 72 provides rules for when a fire alarm system does not need to notify all building occupants of the need to evacuate. In those cases, you will have the option to provide what is known as “Private Operating Mode” notification. NFPA defines this as “Audible or visible signaling only to those persons directly concerned with the implementation and direction of emergency action initiation and procedure in the area protected by the fire alarm system.” Although building and fire codes are primarily concerned with occupant safety, there are going to be several instances where general occupant notification is not desirable. This is usually where the general population (or a large part of it) is incapable of self-rescue, due to their physical or mental condition.

Hospitals and nursing homes are examples of these occupancy types. Inspectors and codes will certainly allow private mode notification in the patient areas; yet in the public and common use areas, such as the cafeteria, gift shop, offices and main hallways, the requirement for public mode notification will prevail. The logic for this is that many of those in a healthcare facility cannot walk. Various conditions and sedatives may cause some patients to not even wake—even if a horn was sounding directly over their bed. In other cases, sudden loud noises and flashing lights can cause much anxiety and overreaction by certain patients and their visitors.

 

Public versus private annunciation modes

There is a passage in NFPA 72, 2010 that states private mode annunciators must be kept from the public’s view and that of the general population: “18.9.3.1 Private Mode. Unless otherwise permitted by the authority having jurisdiction, all textual visible notification appliances in the private mode shall be located in rooms that are accessible only to those persons directly concerned with the implementation and direction of emergency action initiation and procedure in the areas protected by the system.”

Jails and detention centers are other examples where general notification through the use of horns and strobes is not required. The building codes only require that the staff be notified upon activation of waterflow, smoke detection or manual devices. Since these residents are not permitted to go anywhere without strict security measures being taken by the staff, there is no point in adding to the noise and confusion by sounding horns and flashing lights.

 

Other opportunities for sounders

Another opportunity to use Private Mode notification is when a fire alarm system isn’t required by the building or fire code. For example, if your customer is installing automatic detection for the protection of property, it makes sense that they will not be providing general occupant notification. You can safely sell additional protection using smoke/heat detectors wired to your customer’s dual-listed fire-security panel.

In this case, the owner is the AHJ and the level of protection is up to them, not the local building/fire official. (Time out for a rant! OK, before you start to e-mail me about how you know of a local jurisdiction that requires anyone considering adding a few fire alarm devices to their commercial fire alarm system, to do it in an ‘all-or-nothing’ manner, I am aware that there are locales where this is true. And yes, some of those inspectors boast about how they have forced a few restaurants or businesses wishing to add smoke detectors, to add “complete protection,” but these jurisdictions are the exception.)

This content continues onto the next page...