Where Is Wireless Access Control?

The providers are out there, and their solutions aren’t as limited as you may think.

Wireless transmission has long been a subject of technical fascination. Significant advances in wireless burglar alarm systems have made the wired burglar alarm a dinosaur of the security industry. Of late there has also been a sharp increase in the use of wireless connectivity with CCTV systems.

So why not use wireless connectivity for access control applications? Surely wireless communication between the access control panel and readers would offer many benefits. But there's a limited number of serious vendors active in this marketplace. There must be significant reasons for the currently limited use of wireless access control.


Range Limits and the FCC

Wireless connectivity was originally considered to be a solution for cable replacement or elimination. Most manufacturers use ready-made wireless Tx/Rx (transmit-receive) circuit board assemblies for security-related connectivity applications. These devices work in the license-free 900 MHz and 2.4 GHz wireless bands.

The Federal Communication Commission limits the power output of devices that operate in these license-free bands, and limited power can mean limited range. Generally within a building the range is also limited by the steel framing inside the walls. A built-in antenna typically has a range of between 100 and 200 feet. Outside the building, a built-in antenna can typically offer 300 feet. With an external antenna, a range of 1,000 feet is possible, and with a directional Yagi antenna (900 MHz only) you can reach up to five miles.

Most manufacturers use spread spectrum transmission because it provides some data security, and then they add encryption to prevent unauthorized access to the transmitted information.


Some Common Misconceptions

While power and range are legitimate issues, some managers are reluctant to use wireless access control systems because of misconceptions and misunderstandings about what wireless technologies can do. Some examples:

• Wireless is a good solution for only a narrow range of facilities—niche use only

• Wireless communication can be easily compromised

• Wireless communication is expensive

• To install wireless, you'll have to replace your entire existing system

• Concrete and steel make wireless an impossibility


Several Companies Provide Solutions

If you're looking for wireless access control and start your search on Google, you'll find several vendors of wireless computer communications but very little in the area of traditional access control applications. The first page of search results won't include anything on panel-to-reader communication.

You might conclude from this that there are no wireless access control players in the traditional access control marketplace, but that is very far from the truth. In the past few years a number of good and competent manufacturers have stepped up to the plate and have begun producing viable wireless devices and systems.

Most of the manufacturers of wireless access control systems started out as niche systems manufacturers, although some of these companies, including Schlage Wyreless Access, Isonas, Brivo, Cypress Computer Systems, Linear Access and SALock, are coming into their own.


Many Applications, Many Options

Dick Burkley, one of the founders of Isonas and the new president of the company, has indicated that the major motivating reason for a wireless access control implementation is the ease of installation; it avoids the labor, time and cost of wiring. Lester LaPierre, marketing manager for Schlage Wyreless Access (Ingersoll-Rand Security Technologies), claimed that wireless installation can take less than one hour at the door, and the existing UL 10C rating on the door remains intact. This could translate to savings of at least 20% in the overall project labor costs because of the improved efficiency of the installation teams.

La Pierre said, “Many traditional system integrators who are more comfortable installing cable-based systems see this new technology as a tremendous threat to their business.” However, the ease of installation of wireless makes it attractive in a number of situations.

This content continues onto the next page...