Nearly Half of U.S. States Fail on Emergency Plan Communication, New Study Shows

Oct. 21, 2008

Twenty-two states unable or unwilling to provide an emergency operations plan when requested

FAIRFAX, Va. , Oct. 21 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- Seven years after Sept. 11 , and in the wake of many major natural disasters such as forest fires, hurricanes and flooding, nearly half of U.S. states either have no state-level emergency plan or do not provide it readily to the public, reveals a new study by George Mason University Communication Professor Carl Botan .

(Logo: )

Despite federal laws that require a state emergency operations plan (EOP) as a prerequisite to some federal funding, 22 states were unable to provide Botan with an EOP, withheld the plan on security grounds or made it difficult for even trained researchers to gain access. Residents of these states, Botan says, may question their state's preparedness because they are unable to find out how the highest authorities in their state coordinate responses to major disasters or how to have a say in those plans.

"While most Americans will have access to some important state-level information during emergencies, many may not. When minutes may make the difference between life and death in an emergency situation, the population should not have to waste precious time looking for answers or who to turn to," says Botan.

The study, "Using Sense-Making and Co-orientation to Rank Strategic Public Communication in State Emergency Operations Plans," graded and ranked the state emergency operations plans of the 50 U.S. states and the District of Columbia on their communication components.

Botan analyzed the accessible state EOPs for three criteria: if the plans had a two-way communication component, if they addressed the communication needs of vulnerable populations and if they treated public communication as important enough to specifically address it in the plan.

He found that the 29 jurisdictions that do have plans available make provisions for public communication -- including news releases and public broadcasts, but only 16 of them make explicit or implicit provisions for two-way public communication such as community forums and focus groups. Botan feels that two-way public communication is essential in the plans, for that will allow the state to understand what its residents feel they need in emergency situations.

Of the 29 plans obtained, only two -- Washington, D.C. [which is treated as a state-level entity for this purpose] and New Mexico -- received a perfect score of eight for communication.

In addition, while 16 states mentioned vulnerable publics, only 13 of these discussed specific communication strategies for these vulnerable publics in their plans. For example, California mentions specific strategies such as dispatching special teams targeting vulnerable populations like the aged and the disabled, while Arizona simply mentions that emergency managers must pay attention to "special needs" people like residents of nursing homes and the hearing impaired, but does not outline specific strategies to communicate with them.

As of 1988, all states are required under the Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act to have a written EOP in order to qualify for some federal funding. "Billions of tax dollars have been spent on homeland security in the last half-decade," Botan says. "It's very important that these plans are available to the public. Otherwise residents can't be confident their needs have been thought of, and aren't sure who they can count on."

The study, co-authored by George Mason University alumni Paul Penchalapadu, is to be presented at the National Communication Association annual conference in San Diego on Saturday, Nov. 22 . Major results are summarized in Table 1, below.

About George Mason University

Named the #1 national university to watch by U.S. News & World Report, George Mason University is an innovative, entrepreneurial institution with global distinction in a range of academic fields. Located in the heart of Northern Virginia's technology corridor near Washington, D.C. , Mason prepares its students to succeed in the work force and meet the needs of the region and the world. With strong undergraduate and graduate degree programs in engineering and information technology, dance, organizational psychology and health care, Mason students are routinely recognized with national and international scholarships. Mason professors conduct groundbreaking research in areas such as cancer, climate change, information technology and the biosciences, and Mason's Center for the Arts brings world-renowned artists, musicians and actors to its stage.

Table 1 RQ 1: Two way RQ 2: Vulnerable communication Populations Two way Phone Specific If no strategies lines strategies strategy, employed only employed mention? DC 4 2 New Mexico 4 2 Ohio 4 1 New Hampshire 2 2 Vermont 2 2 Georgia 2 2 South Carolina 2 2 Mississippi 2 2 Nebraska 2 2 Alaska 2 1 Arizona 2 1 Virginia 2 0 Maine 0 2 Oregon 2 0 Pennsylvania 0 2 Oklahoma 0 2 North Carolina 2 0 Texas 2 0 Alabama 2 0 Rhode Island 0 2 California 0 2 Wisconsin 0 0 North Dakota 0 0 Kentucky 0 0 West Virginia 0 0 Washington 0 0 Colorado 0 0 Louisiana 0 0 Utah 0 0 RQ 3: Separate Component Total Separate If no Score component component, present mention? DC 2 8 New Mexico 2 8 Ohio 2 7 New Hampshire 2 6 Vermont 2 6 Georgia 2 6 South Carolina 2 6 Mississippi 2 6 Nebraska 1 5 Alaska 2 5 Arizona 2 5 Virginia 2 4 Maine 2 4 Oregon 2 4 Pennsylvania 2 4 Oklahoma 2 4 North Carolina 2 4 Texas 2 4 Alabama 2 4 Rhode Island 1 3 California 1 3 Wisconsin 2 2 North Dakota 2 2 Kentucky 2 2 West Virginia 2 2 Washington 2 2 Colorado 2 2 Louisiana 2 2 Utah 2 2

SOURCE George Mason University

Copyright © 2008 PR Newswire Association LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Sponsored Recommendations

Attack of the zombie APIs

Who is leading the security counteroffensive in your organization?

Metrasens Ultra detection technology real-time integration with Milestone X-Protect

The integration classifies events and alarms from Metrasens Ultra’s five detection zones, as well as all five levels of signal strength, allowing system operators to easily identify...

Metropolitan Security Services launches 100% online security training

Metropolitan Security Services' top-of-the-line training courses are available for purchase for those seeking to begin their security career or expand their knowledge of industry...

Allied Universal's Christian LaCour honored posthumously for heroism displayed during mass shooting

The LaCour family has established a GoFundMe page to honor Christian and help with expenses following the unexpected tragedy.